Vladimir Putin told a filmmaker that Moscow is the Third Rome. The phrase is old, and he was not the first to use it. A companion claim, that the communists created Ukraine, treats a Soviet map as if it were the country’s beginning.
This piece draws on two posts by Rina Lu (@rinalu_): her Friday post on Moscow as the Third Rome, and, a week earlier, a claim that the communists created Ukraine.
On November 20, the Kremlin published Vladimir Putin’s interview with the Serbian filmmaker Emir Kusturica, timed to Patriarch Kirill’s 80th birthday. Putin said Russian thought had long centered on one idea: “Moscow is the Third Rome, a fourth there shall not be.” “Guys, this idea is over 500 years old,” she wrote. “So Putin wasn’t announcing some revolutionary new doctrine.”
The genealogy is documented. Constantine dedicated Constantinople as the Roman capital in 330, and the Eastern empire lasted until the Ottoman conquest in 1453. In 1472, Ivan III, Grand Prince of Moscow, married Sophia Palaiologina, niece of the last Byzantine emperor, Constantine XI. In 1523 or 1524, the Pskov monk Philotheus, or Filofei, wrote that two Romes had fallen, a third stood, and a fourth there would not be.
Rina is right that the formula is old. She is too quick to leave it there. In the official transcript, after the history lesson, Putin added that the idea “is not the main point here. It is all about today.” He agreed that Russia could be an “ark” for traditional values. The 62-second clip she posted ends at “the spiritual guardian of this heritage.” It does not include what he said next.
A reply from NekoKieLove added no caption, only a four-and-a-half-minute video of a vast khaki-and-gold Orthodox cathedral on a circular plaza: the Main Cathedral of the Russian Armed Forces, consecrated in 2020 at Patriot Park, west of Moscow.
A week earlier, Rina had made the harder claim. “Ukraine has spent the last ten years decommunizing itself. Awkward, because the communists are the ones who created Ukraine. Lenin founded it, borders and all.” Her video, “What Ukraine Really Is,” walks through later border additions by Stalin and Khrushchev. “As an independent state,” she wrote, “it’s 35 years old.”
The map history is largely real, and it undercuts her own punch line. The Ukrainian SSR was proclaimed in Kharkiv on December 24–25, 1917, by a Bolshevik congress. A November 1939 law, after the Soviet invasion of Poland, incorporated western Ukraine, including Lviv, into that republic. In 1945, Czechoslovakia ceded Transcarpathia to the Soviet Union for the same purpose. On February 19, 1954, the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Soviet transferred Crimea from the Russian SFSR. Independent Ukraine kept those republican borders. The Verkhovna Rada declared independence on August 24, 1991; from that act, the modern state is 35 years old.
What does not follow is that the communists “created Ukraine,” or that Lenin founded it “borders and all.” Weeks before the Kharkiv congress, the Central Rada in Kyiv had already proclaimed the Ukrainian People’s Republic; on January 22, 1918, it declared that republic independent. Ukraine has been removing Soviet monuments and place names under decommunization laws adopted in 2015. That is a fight with the Soviet inheritance, not evidence that Ukraine began in a Bolshevik meeting hall. Rina’s own map already shows the 1991 border was assembled over decades, not drawn by Lenin alone.
The Third Rome formula is old, and Putin was reciting it, not inventing it. He was also putting it to a present-day use. The Soviet map of Ukraine is a matter of record. It is not the origin of the country.
Original posts: Rina Lu on the Third Rome and on Ukraine’s Soviet borders, and the video reply from NekoKieLove.