A viral post says a 24-year-old Steve Jobs made one of the best deals in Silicon Valley history, trading a sliver of Apple for a tour of Xerox PARC. The bargain is real. The story that Apple simply stole the desktop is not.
Yesterday, the account 查百万 (@chakmillion) retold a Valley legend. In the winter of 1979, a 24-year-old Steve Jobs let Xerox’s venture arm buy a sliver of pre-IPO Apple for $1 million, and in exchange walked Apple’s core engineers into Xerox PARC in Palo Alto. The post says Xerox’s copier-era bosses agreed because they could not see what their scientists had built; that Jobs then had his team work overnight on the Macintosh; and that Xerox later sued, too late, after realizing it had “given away” hundreds of billions of dollars. A split photograph travels with the tale: Jobs at an Apple Lisa, his hand on a one-button mouse, and a Xerox Alto in a museum, its three-button mouse still at the side.
The bargain is documented. Xerox Development Corporation bought 100,000 shares at $10 each — about $1 million. When Apple went public on 12 December 1980, those shares, split-adjusted to 800,000, were worth about $17.6 million at the $22 opening price. There were two visits in late 1979; Jobs attended the later, fuller demonstration in December. Larry Tesler showed the Alto: a bitmapped screen, a mouse, overlapping windows, and Smalltalk. Tesler later recalled Jobs pacing the room and asking why Xerox was not doing anything with it. Adele Goldberg refused to give the Smalltalk demo. Management overruled her.
What was already under way
Apple did not walk in empty-handed. Work on the Lisa had started in 1978. Jef Raskin, who helped arrange the visits, was already sketching the Macintosh and arguing for a bitmapped machine. The demos confirmed that instinct, and hardened Jobs’s demand for menus, windows, and a mouse on the computer Apple would actually sell.
What Apple had to build
A tour is not a product, and nobody shipped a Macintosh overnight. Xerox’s mouse had three buttons and a costly mechanism. In 1980 the firm Hovey-Kelley — later part of IDEO — engineered a cheaper, reliable mouse for Lisa; Apple settled on one button after deciding that extras confused beginners. Bill Atkinson wrote QuickDraw’s “regions,” a patented way to clip and redraw overlapping windows. The Mac’s menu bar, trash can, and click-and-double-click grammar were designed at Apple, not copied off the Alto. Lisa reached the market in January 1983 and failed commercially. The Macintosh followed on 24 January 1984. Xerox had already shipped the Star 8010 in April 1981, at $16,595 a workstation — a prelude to its retreat from personal computers. The Alto was never locked in a cabinet. Thousands of visitors had already seen it.
The lesson, not the heist
Bill Gates’s 1983 crack to Jobs still does too much work: that they both had “a rich neighbor named Xerox,” and Gates had broken in only to find Jobs had already stolen the television. Xerox sued Apple in December 1989 over the Star interface; a federal judge dismissed the case in 1990, in part because it came too late. Jobs paid for access. Apple re-engineered what it saw. Xerox took the stock and, when it did commercialize, shipped a machine the market would not buy at the price. A research lab that does not ship does not usually lose the future to a burglar. It loses it in the building. The same trap sits in front of incumbents spending fortunes on artificial intelligence they cannot turn into a product, and startups that treat a dazzling demo as a business. Keep the bargain. Don’t turn it into a theft.